AleSmith Stumblin' Monk

An Alesmith bottle-conditioned beer that I can't find a reason to jump up and shout about??? Yes, it's true -- this is a good beer, but not a great beer.

Had this in my "cellar" since early July 2001, and finally decided to pop it open August 2003. In retrospect, I think it would have been better around Summer 2002, but them's the breaks. As such, this is all I have to go on, review-wise. Caveat Emptor.

First impressions: Not nearly as interesting or as complex as most Belgian Strong Pale Ales. Duvel, this aint. In fact, I'm not very proud to say that I was kinda bored with this beer. Had a full 0,5L glass of this, and tossed the rest down the sink. The Avery Quadruppel was calling my name, and life's too short for so-so beer!

That's a bit harsh, actually. But to be honest, this was way too basic and dull for a beer with such promise. Again, I suspect that I aged this too long. But until a newer version of this beer shows up, it's strictly "buyer beware", IMO.
//TB

P.S. This beer has since been discontinued.


6 Random BrewReviews

Who doesn't like a six-pack of good beer? Here's a random selection of six BrewReviews, for your browsing and drinking pleasure:

6 Random PubReviews

Looking for a beer out in town on on the road? Here's a random selection of six PubReviews, for your browsing and drinking pleasure:

13 Recent Reviews

A "baker's dozen" of every BrewReview and PubReview recently submitted to the site. You can also sort Alphabetically. Cheers!
Datesort icon Name Score
September 6, 2010
United States
A few beers for my 40th birthday 7
September 6, 2010
Italy
A few beers for my 40th birthday 7
September 2, 2010
United States
Mammoth - Real McCoy Amber Ale 7
September 2, 2010
United States
He'Brew Rejewvenator 2010 (Year of the Grape) 6
August 26, 2010
Japan
Ozeno Yukidoke IPA 8
August 25, 2010
United States
Noble Ale Works IPA 5
August 24, 2010
United States
Noble Ale Works Pale Ale 5
August 24, 2010
United States
Mammoth Brewing Golden Trout Pilsner Beer 2
August 23, 2010
England
Laverstoke Organic Ale 5
August 23, 2010
Japan
Ise Kadoya Triple Hop Ale 8
August 23, 2010
United States
Drake's IPA 8
August 22, 2010
United States
Abner Weed Amber Ale 5
August 19, 2010
Ireland
Curim Gold Celtic Wheat Beer 6

BrewReview by Todd Bissell is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. BrewReview.info claims no ownership to any trademarks or images displayed on the site. All trademarks, registered brands, and images displayed on the site remain the exclusive property of the owner. The Rest is © 2003-2010 Todd Bissell | Contact: admin|at|brewreview|dot|info.